Jane Austen Book Club

As a followup to last month's discussion on "Persuasion", we will be watching the movie of the same name for the August meeting of the Jane Austen Book Club.  We will meet at 5:00 pm in the McIntyre Room, in the Carnegie building on August 10th.  Which version shall we watch?  Both the 1995 version, starring Ciaran Hinds and Amanda Root, and the 2007 versions, starring Sally Hawkins and Rubert Penry-Jones were commissioned for Masterpiece Theatre with the 1995 version debuting in theaters, a first for Masterpiece.  The 1995 version is beautifully filmed and was awarded a NY times Critics Pick.  Here's the review.  The 2007 version was filmed for the recent "All Jane Austen marathon" on Masterpiece that year.  I like them both.  So help me pick.  Comment on which version you think we should show. 

1995 

2007